Small, Mini & Beginner Butt Plugs

Products List

Filters

Sort By:

Display Type:
  • Pink Paw Paw silicone butt plug with paw print detail and pink jewel base
    NEW IN
    NEW IN

    Paw Paw Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Leave a little paw print where no one expects it. The Paw Paw Plug is a petite silicone butt plug with a smooth teardrop shape, a playful paw motif and a faceted jewel base for a cheeky flash of...
  • Black silicone anal training plugs with curved anchor bases on soft pink background
    NEW IN
    NEW IN

    3 Piece Black Silicone Anal Training Set

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎59
    This 3 piece black silicone anal training set gives you three different ways to explore pressure and fullness. Start with the rounded plug for a fuller single stretch, move into the double-bulb shape...
  • 5 piece black silicone anal training set with plugs, beads, and curved base shapes
    NEW IN
    NEW IN

    5 Piece Black Silicone Anal Training Set

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎45
    This 5 piece black silicone anal training set gives you different shapes to explore instead of locking you into one feeling. Start with the smaller teardrop plug, move into smoother pressure with the...
  • Red tassel metal butt plug with polished silver teardrop plug, decorative bell, and charm ring

    Red Tassel Butt Plug with Bell

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎23
    Bold, glossy, and impossible to ignore. This red tassel metal butt plug with bell combines a smooth silver plug with a diameter of 2.5 cm (0.98 in), a vibrant red tassel, and a playful bell. The...
  • Pink tassel metal butt plug with silver teardrop plug, decorative bell, and charm ring

    Pink Tassel Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎23

    (1)

    Sweet, shiny, and teasing. This pink tassel metal butt plug combines a smooth silver metal plug with a diameter of 2.5 cm (0.98 in), a playful pink tassel and decorative bell. The polished metal...
  • Silver metal butt plug with black tassel, decorative bell, and charm ring

    Black Tassel Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎23
    Dark, polished, and quietly dominant. This black tassel metal butt plug with a diameter of 2.5 cm (0.98 in) is made for more than just fullness. The smooth metal plug delivers a cool, firm sensation...
  • Curved black fox tail anal plug lying flat

    Teardrop Black Fox Tail Anal Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎29
    Soft, playful, and made to move naturally with every step. Soft, fluffy, and easy to wear, this black fox tail anal plug is made for playful pet play without feeling too intense. The slim teardrop...
  • Beaded black fox tail anal plug with oversized faux fur tail

    Ripple Bead Black Fox Tail Anal Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎29
    Textured movement with a softer pet play look. Fluffy on the outside, more playful on the inside. The ripple bead silicone plug adds gentle texture with each rounded section, creating more sensation...
  • Curved black fox tail anal plug with long soft tail

    Pear-Shaped Black Fox Tail Anal Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎29
    Fuller shape. More pressure. More attention from behind. Soft pet play meets a fuller, more noticeable fit. The pear-shaped silicone plug has a rounded body that feels more present once worn, while...

Got more questions? Ask Monique here!

Still Exploring?

Dive deeper with our expert-backed guides

June 11, 2025

Looking for something else?

Find Your Kink. Shop With Confidence.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Rachel S.

A one-stop shop for everyone with different kinks and fetishes.

I'm into femdom, and The Lollipop Shop has everything I need. Whether you're into BDSM, femdom, pet play or something more specific, they've got it all. Highly recommend!

Rachel S.

Tony L.

I love the variety of kinks.

I love the variety of kinks The Lollipop Shop caters to. Got everything.

Tony L.

Laura D.

Will order again!

I ordered some pumps, plugs and nipple clamps. The clamps, they hurt so good. Defs not for beginners! Will order again!

Laura D.

Olivia T.

Into extreme bondage

I'm into extreme bondage, and the gear doesn't disappoint. The sleep sacks fit really well and the hoods are solid. There's no getting out once you're locked in.

Olivia T.

Alex W.

I'll be coming back for more.

Just got the full pup play gear set and a couple of animal dildos, and it is super! The pup hood, tail plug, and mitts are all high quality and fit perfectly.

Alex W.

Tom M.

Worth every penny.

The restraints I bought are indestructible. My sub couldn't move. Worth every penny.

Tom M.

Best Sellers

Some of our best sellers