Butt Plug Sets

Filter By

Products List

Filters

Sort By:

Display Type:
  • Polished zinc alloy butt plug with a red round jewel at the base, showcasing its reflective surface and smooth, tapered design. Side view of a zinc alloy butt plug with a round jewel, highlighting the sleek design and shiny finish.

    Red Twilight Sparkle Round Jewel Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    This elegant anal toy is designed to delight both visually and sensually. Each plug is adorned with a magnificent round jewel at the base, catching the light and adding a glamorous sparkle to your playtime. Its smooth, tapered design facilitates...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Red Gem Anchor Zinc Alloy Butt Plug with reflective surface and red gem detail. Red Gem Anchor Zinc Alloy Butt Plug with reflective surface and red gem detail.

    Red Gem Anchor Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎25

    (1)

    The anchor shape of our Red Gem Anchor Butt Plug ensures not only effortless insertion but also a gratifyingly secure experience, perfect for those who seek both comfort and excitement in their explorative play. Features Material: Crafted from...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Red Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with small blue bells Red Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with small blue bells

    Red Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with Bells

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎25
    Embark on an enchanting journey of intimate exploration with the Red Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with Bells. This beautifully crafted anal plug combines the polished elegance of aluminum alloy with a dazzling red heart jewel, complemented by delightful...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Blue Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with small blue bells Close-up of red heart jewel on metal butt plug

    Blue Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with Bells

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎25
    Embark on an enchanting journey of intimate exploration with the Blue Heart Jewel Metal Butt Plug with Bells. This beautifully crafted anal plug combines the polished elegance of aluminum alloy with a dazzling blue heart jewel, complemented by delightful...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Blue heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Blue heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play.

    Blue Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Blue Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth, body-safe...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • White heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. White heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play.

    White Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22

    (5)

    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the White Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth,...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Yellow heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Yellow heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play.

    Yellow Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22

    (1)

    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Yellow Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth,...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Black heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Elegant metal butt plug with a romantic black heart jewel, perfect for gift-giving or personal indulgence.

    Black Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Black Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth,...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Light pink heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Elegant metal butt plug with a romantic light pink heart jewel, perfect for gift-giving or personal indulgence.

    Light Pink Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Light Pink Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth,...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Elegant metal butt plug with a romantic purple heart jewel, perfect for gift-giving or personal indulgence. Purple heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play.

    Purple Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22

    (1)

    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Purple Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth,...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Pink heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Elegant metal butt plug with a romantic pink heart jewel, perfect for gift-giving or personal indulgence.

    Pink Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Pink Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth, body-safe...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Light blue heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Elegant metal butt plug with a romantic light blue heart jewel, perfect for gift-giving or personal indulgence.

    Light Blue Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Light Blue Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth,...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
  • Red heart jewel metal butt plug on a reflective surface, ideal for enhancing anal play. Elegant metal butt plug with a romantic red heart jewel, perfect for gift-giving or personal indulgence.

    Red Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug

    $‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‏‏‎22
    Is romance sparking in the air, or is it igniting a delightful surprise in your rear? Presenting the Red Jewel Love Heart Metal Butt Plug, this exquisite anal toy is the perfect blend of elegance and pleasure. Each plug is crafted from smooth, body-safe...
    Choose Options
    Choose Options
    Quick view
More Butt Plugs

Which size should I start with in a beginner butt plug set?

Start small. Use plenty of water-based lube. Take breaks.

When insertion and removal feel smooth, step to medium. If anything pinches, go back a size.

Got more questions? Ask Monique here!

Still Exploring?

Dive deeper with our expert-backed guides

Butt Plug Sets: Why Graduated Sizes Speed Up Training

October 14th, 2025

Looking for something else?

For Beginners
For Advanced Players
For Extreme Players

Recently Viewed

It exceeded my expectations.
I ordered a bondage set from the Lollipop Shop,
and it exceeded my expectations. The quality is fantastic!
Sarah T.
Will shop here again!
Fast shipping and discreet packaging were exactly
what I was looking for. Will shop here again!
Emma L.
Customer service was so helpful.
I had some product questions, and Monique was quick
to respond, and her customer service was so helpful.
Mark P.
Worth every penny.
The restraints I bought are indestructible. My sub
couldn't move. Worth every penny.
Tom M.
My favorite toy.
I got a strap-on, and it's now my favorite toy.
Comfortable, secure, and incredibly fun to use. My
partner and I have had some of our best sessions with it.
Emily J.
Into extreme bondage
I'm into extreme bondage, and the gear doesn't disappoint.
The sleep sacks fit really well and the hoods are solid.
There's no getting out once you're locked in.
Olivia T.
Delivered quickly... and top-quality. Will be back!
I purchased multiple items. It was delivered quickly, very
happy with all products, been using a while and they're
top-quality. Will be back!
Zoe D.
It's perfect
I ordered a chastity cage, and it's perfect. Tight, secure,
and now all locked up.
Mark A.
Best customer service
Had a few questions regarding the products, and Monique
responded, and was awesome! Quick to respond, and
answered my questions, and provided great recommendations.
I ended up purchasing speculums, gloves and nipple clamps.
Honestly, best customer service I've had in a while.
Katie K.
I'll be coming back for more.
Just got the full pup play gear set and a couple of animal dildos,
and is super! The pup hood, tail plug, and mitts are all super high
quality and fit perfectly, making it easy to get fully into
character. The animal dildos realism is wild. Everything's built to
last through some seriously intense sessions. If you're into pet
play, this shop is a must. I'll be coming back for more.
Alex W.
A one-stop shop for everyone with different kinks and fetishes.
I'm into femdom, and the lollipop shop has everything I need.
What makes the lollipop shop stand out is the range of gear for all
kinds of fetishes and kinks. Whether you're into BDSM, femdom,
pet play or something more specific, they've got it all. It's a one-stop
shop for everyone with different kinks and fetishes. Highly recommend! 
Rachel S.
I love the variety of kinks.
I love the variety of kinks the lollipop shop caters to.
Got everything.
Tony L.
Customer service is amazing.
Their customer service is amazing. Had an issue with my order,
but they fixed it right away. Shoutout to Quentin!
Jess R.
Will order again!
I ordered some pumps, plugs and nipple clamps. The clamps, they
hurt so good. Defs not for beginners! Will order again!
Laura D.
Products are very good.
Shipping took about a week, was happy with that.
Arrived in plain packaging, no awkward moments with
the mailman. Products are very good. No complaints.
Jamie A.

Best Sellers

Some of our best sellers